Home Comparisons
TapeSheet vs the alternatives
Six comparisons, each built from public prices and public documentation, and each with an explicit section on what that product does better than TapeSheet. There are no affiliate links on any of them.
| Product | Price | Signup | Your trades |
|---|---|---|---|
| TapeSheet | Free, no tier | None | Never leave your device |
| TradeZella | $35 / $59 / $99 per month | Account and card required | Processed on their servers |
| Myfxbook | Free | Account required | Live account linked by investor password, server-side |
| TradesViz | Free to 3,000 executions/month; $19 or $29 per month | Account required | Processed on their servers |
| Edgewonk | $169 per year, flat | Account and payment required | File imports; desktop-origin product |
| Tradelytic | Free forever | Account required | Processed on their servers |
| Tradervue | Free tier (30 trades/mo, stocks only); $29.95–49.95 per month | Account required | Processed on their servers |
Read the one you came for
- TradeZellaYou cannot find out whether TradeZella parses your broker’s file until after you have paid for it. 4 things TradeZella does better than us, listed on the page.
- MyfxbookMyfxbook reports. It does not review. 4 things Myfxbook does better than us, listed on the page.
- TradesVizA scalper burns 3,000 executions in a week. We do not count your trades. 3 things TradesViz does better than us, listed on the page.
- Edgewonk$169 up front, before you find out whether it reads your broker’s file. 3 things Edgewonk does better than us, listed on the page.
- TradelyticAlso free. But it wants an account, and your broker credentials. 4 things Tradelytic does better than us, listed on the page.
- TradervueFor forex you are paying about $30 a month for the privilege of uploading a file. 3 things Tradervue does better than us, listed on the page.
Why these are worth trusting, and how to check
Comparison queries are dominated by affiliate sites, and an affiliate comparison has one job: send you to whichever product pays the most per referral. That is why every one of them concludes that the product with the best affiliate programme is the best product.
We take no affiliate money from anyone on this list, and we take no referral fees from brokers or prop firms either. Our income is ad units on content pages — this one included — and the ethics page spells out exactly what that does and does not buy. You do not have to take that on trust: this site makes zero requests to any third party, so there is no tracking link, no redirect, and no affiliate tag to find. Open the network tab.
The second check is easier. Every page names things the competitor does better, in specific terms, and several of those are features we have decided we will never build. A page that concedes tick-by-tick replay, an eighty-broker integration list and a prop-compliance engine years ahead of ours is not trying to sell you something.
Where we lose, in one place
If you would rather not read six pages: TradeZella has trade replay, backtesting and AI that we do not and will not have. TradesViz has a prop-firm compliance engine years ahead of our tracker, and deeper analytics. Myfxbook has a community, live tracking and verified public track records. Edgewonk thinks harder about psychology. Tradervue has eighty-plus broker integrations and fifteen years of existing. Tradelytic has nightly sync, an iOS app and AI, and is free too.
What TapeSheet has is narrow and, we think, worth more than it sounds: it is free with no tier, it needs no account, it reads MT4 and MT5 statements as its primary flow rather than a fallback, and your trading history never leaves your device — because there is no server to send it to.
Or just try it — there is nothing to sign up for
Drop an MT4 or MT5 statement on the page. Full dashboard in about three seconds, no account, no upload. If it does not read your broker’s file you have lost thirty seconds.
Analyze my statementFree trading journal ·MT4 statement analyzer ·MT5 report analyzer ·Metrics glossary ·Calculators
TapeSheet is an independent product and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to any product named on this page. All product names are used nominatively, to identify the products being compared. No competitor screenshots, logos, icons, illustrations, copy or styling appear anywhere on this site.